Maryland Certified Residential Appraiser — 37+ Years of Baltimore Area Experience
Updated November 15, 2026 · By Ed Drost, Maryland Certified Residential Appraiser #30004874
Anneslie, Rodgers Forge and Stoneleigh are Baltimore County communities just north of the Baltimore City line, with ZIP code 21212 addresses (Anneslie, Rodgers Forge, Stoneleigh). Wiltondale is the next community north, and its addresses are typically listed as 21204 or 21286 rather than 21212. All four sit close together near York Road in the Towson area, yet their homes compete in different parts of the market.
That is why ZIP-wide averages and automated estimates are unreliable here. An attached brick rowhouse in Rodgers Forge and a detached home in Stoneleigh are different property types with different buyers. A credible appraisal identifies the correct submarket, selects comparables a buyer would genuinely treat as substitutes, and supports each adjustment with market evidence.
| Neighborhood | Typical housing stock | Historic status | What drives value |
|---|---|---|---|
| Anneslie | Detached homes: bungalows, Foursquares, Cape Cods, Tudor and Colonial Revival | National Register district, listed March 12, 2012 | Size and additions, condition, basement finish, parking, lot |
| Rodgers Forge | Brick rowhouses, about 1,800 households | National Register district, listed September 24, 2009 | Interior vs. end-of-group position, floor plan, garage and parking, kitchen, bath and basement updates |
| Stoneleigh | Larger detached homes: Colonial Revival, Classical Revival and other traditional styles | National Register district, listed November 8, 2003 | Size, architecture and condition, lot and landscaping, additions, thin comparable pool |
| Wiltondale | Detached homes, many Colonial and traditional styles | Not covered in this section; verify status with MHT | Size, renovations, lot, functional layout, community pool membership (verify terms) |
Facts above come from the Maryland Historical Trust National Register records and the Rodgers Forge Community Association. Housing descriptions also reflect my own appraisal experience in this market.
The Maryland Historical Trust lists the Anneslie Historic District (BA-3200) as 503 resources, 475 of them contributing, built between 1922 and 1961, and describes it as a suburban subdivision east of York Road immediately north of the City line. The district is named for the Anneslie estate, and the Villa Anneslie house, dated 1855 in National Park Service records, still stands at 529 Dunkirk Road (Maryland Historical Trust; Wikipedia).
Appraisal considerations:
The Maryland Historical Trust describes Rodgers Forge as an approximately 150-acre, primarily rowhouse suburban community built by developer James Keelty and his sons between 1931 and 1957. It was listed in the National Register on September 24, 2009. The Rodgers Forge Community Association describes roughly 1,800 households, the overwhelming majority in brick rowhomes built from the 1930s into the 1950s.
Appraisal considerations:
The Stoneleigh Historic District (BA-2974) was listed in the National Register on November 8, 2003, with a period of construction of 1922 to 1954 according to the Maryland Historical Trust. National Park Service records give its approximate boundaries as Regester Avenue, York Road, Hatherleigh Road and Kenleigh Road, and list Colonial Revival and Classical Revival among its styles (Wikipedia).
Appraisal considerations:
Wiltondale is a detached-home neighborhood in the Towson area. Current listings describe a community pool, playground and picnic area available through voluntary association membership, and the Wiltondale Improvement Association is a registered nonprofit whose stated activity is community improvement and the community pool. Because listing descriptions and membership terms change, verify current membership and any covenants with the Association and the property's deed records.
An appraiser must separate neighborhood appeal from the measurable market contribution of an amenity: homes with and without pool membership should be compared only where sales evidence supports a difference. As with the other neighborhoods, size, condition, lot and layout come first.
Neighborhood boundaries, association membership and school assignments can change. Confirm current details with the relevant association and the Baltimore County Public Schools before relying on them.
A Baltimore City sale can sometimes serve as a comparable for a County home, but its use must be explained and supported by market evidence. The boundary does not by itself justify a fixed adjustment. Looking for Homeland, Cedarcroft or Govans? See my Baltimore City ZIP 21212 page.
For an appraisal, the practical question is what buyers in the market recognize and pay for. Designation can shape renovation choices and buyer preferences, but any value adjustment must be supported by sales evidence. Check eligibility, approvals and deadlines with the Maryland Historical Trust before starting tax-credit work.
These are independent public and community resources, listed for homeowner research. Residential Appraisal Solutions, LLC is not affiliated with them. Assessment, sale price and appraisal are different measures and should not be treated as interchangeable.
Many South Towson homes stay in families for decades. When an owner passes away, the estate needs a supported value as of the date of death, with comparable sales chosen carefully in a market of limited, varied sales. See my estate and probate appraisal page.
Dividing a jointly owned Anneslie, Rodgers Forge, Stoneleigh or Wiltondale home calls for an independent certified appraisal that identifies the correct submarket and supports its conclusions with market evidence.
Establishing what a South Towson property was worth in a prior year takes real knowledge of how these neighborhoods traded then. I draw on 37+ years of Baltimore area market records for accurate retrospective valuations.
If your home has appreciated since you bought it, a certified lender-grade appraisal documenting current value may help you remove private mortgage insurance, subject to your lender's requirements.
Know your home's accurate market value before listing in Anneslie, Rodgers Forge, Stoneleigh or Wiltondale. A certified independent appraisal from a 37-year Baltimore area expert gives you objective data and negotiating confidence.
When an SDAT assessment looks wrong, a supported opinion of value with comparable sales can serve as evidence. Assessment appeal guide.
As an FHA-approved appraiser, I provide lender-required appraisals for purchase and refinance transactions throughout the South Towson area of Baltimore County.
I've been appraising Baltimore area homes since 1989, including Anneslie, Rodgers Forge, Stoneleigh and the surrounding South Towson communities. Each of these neighborhoods needs an appraiser who knows which homes truly compete with one another, how additions and renovations change a property's market appeal, and where comparable sales must come from.
When an estate needs accurate documentation or a divorce needs an independent certified valuation, I bring 37+ years of direct market knowledge to produce a report that holds up under scrutiny.
Maryland Certified · USPAP Compliant · Planned Community Specialist · 37+ Years Baltimore Area Experience
443-904-5229 Call Now — Free Consultation