Home › Articles › Zillow, SDAT or Appraiser: Which Value Wins?
Use the value that matches the job. A Zillow estimate is a free starting point. A Maryland SDAT assessment is a tax figure, not a market price. A certified appraisal is the right tool when the number has to hold up for a lender, a court, an estate or a tax appeal. For listing, an agent's market analysis and a pre-listing appraisal work well together.
In my first article, How Much Is My Baltimore House Really Worth?, I explained why Zillow, the state assessment and a local appraisal disagree. The next question I hear is the practical one: so which one do I use?
My answer, after appraising Baltimore-area homes since September 1989, is that no single number is the "real" value. Each one is built for a different purpose. Use the wrong one and you can make an expensive mistake.
What is each number actually built to do?
- Zillow's estimate is a computer model. It is fast and free, and it can be reasonable on a typical home with many recent sales nearby. It cannot walk through your house or see a finished basement, a bad roof or a renovated kitchen.
- The SDAT assessment is a tax figure. Maryland reassesses each property every three years, and increases are phased in over that period. It exists to divide the tax burden, not to predict a sale price.
- An appraisal is a professional opinion of value for a specific purpose and date, based on an inspection and verified comparable sales.
Which value should you use?
| Your situation | Best starting point | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Curious about your home's value | Zillow, as a rough guide | Free and fast, but treat it as a ballpark |
| Pricing a home to sell | An agent's market analysis, plus a pre-listing appraisal if the stakes are high | Two independent views of the same market |
| Buying or refinancing | The lender's appraisal | The lender lends against it |
| Disputing your property tax | A comparable-sales case, often with an appraisal | See the assessment appeal guide |
| Settling an estate | A date-of-death appraisal | Estate and tax records need a documented value |
| Divorce buyout | A divorce appraisal | Both sides need a neutral, defensible number |
| Removing PMI | A lender-accepted appraisal | The servicer sets the rules |
Why shouldn't you use the tax assessment as your sale price?
Because it is a different measure on a different schedule. Phase-in rules can make an assessment lag the market for years, and mass-appraisal methods cannot see individual condition. If you think your assessment is too high, the appeal deadline is short, generally 45 days from the date of the notice, so check your notice and act early.
What if two numbers disagree wildly?
That is useful information. A big gap between Zillow and a recent comparable sale usually points to something the model cannot see: condition, an addition, a ground rent issue or an unusual block. This is exactly where a local appraiser earns the fee. See what it costs in my Baltimore Home Appraisal Cost Guide.
Common questions
Is a real estate agent's market analysis the same as an appraisal?
No. An agent's analysis helps you set a price and is not a formal opinion of value prepared to appraisal standards. For many sellers, having both is the best approach.
Can I use Zillow for a probate or tax filing?
Generally not. These situations usually need a documented value from a qualified appraiser. I explain why in Can I Use a CMA for Probate Instead of an Appraisal?
How accurate is Zillow in Baltimore?
Zillow publishes its own accuracy figures: a small median error for homes on the market and a much larger error for homes that are not listed. Older rowhouses and homes with unusual features tend to be harder for any model.
The bottom line
Stop asking which number is right. Ask what you need the number for. Match the value to the job, and you will make better decisions with less stress.
Not sure which number fits your situation? Call me and I will point you the right way.
Sources
- Maryland SDAT: Real Property Assessments and Appeals
- Zillow: What is a Zestimate and how accurate is it?
- Fannie Mae Selling Guide B4-1.2-01: Appraisal Report Forms and Exhibits
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. All dollar examples are hypothetical and rules change, so confirm current requirements with your lender, a Maryland attorney, your CPA or a title company.