Home › Articles › Challenge a Low Home Appraisal: 5 Steps
Yes, you can challenge a low appraisal, but only with facts. The five steps: get the report, check it for errors, submit a reconsideration of value with closed comparable sales, renegotiate or split the gap if the number holds, and decide whether to bring cash or walk away if your contract allows. FHA has different rules than conventional loans.
I am Ed Drost, a Maryland State Certified Residential Appraiser and FHA appraiser. I have appraised homes across Baltimore City and Baltimore, Carroll and Harford counties since 1989, and I answer these questions every week for buyers, sellers and families. This article is part of our Baltimore appraisal Q&A series.
Why do appraisals come in low?
I appraise homes every week, and the most common reason is plain: the appraiser has to support the value with closed sales, and a contract price in a hot week may be ahead of what has closed. A bidding war can push a price above recent comparables. The appraisal looks backward at sales, and the contract reflects what two people agreed to today.
The other reasons are fixable. The report may have the wrong square footage, miss a renovation, or use comparables that do not fit the house, such as a different style or a sale across a neighborhood boundary. Those are the ones worth fighting.
What does a low appraisal cost in dollars?
A lender lends against the lower of the price or the appraised value. Here is an example on a house under contract at $400,000 with an 80% loan, assuming the appraisal comes in at $385,000.
| Outcome | Price | Loan (80% of $385,000) | Cash the buyer brings |
|---|---|---|---|
| Planned, if the appraisal had matched | $400,000 | $320,000 | $80,000 |
| Buyer covers the gap | $400,000 | $308,000 | $92,000 |
| Seller drops to the appraised value | $385,000 | $308,000 | $77,000 |
| Split the $15,000 gap | $392,500 | $308,000 | $84,500 |
The loan drops by $12,000 in every scenario, because it follows the appraisal. The only thing the negotiation changes is who bears the difference. For more on contract language, see appraisal gap clauses and waivers.
What are the five steps?
- Get the full report. Ask your lender for it the day it is done. You are entitled to a copy.
- Check it for facts. Compare living area, bedrooms, baths, lot size, condition and improvements against your plans, permits and measurements. Fix errors first, because they are the strongest argument.
- Ask for a reconsideration of value. This is the ROV, a written request through the lender with closed comparable sales. It costs nothing and sometimes works. It is not guaranteed. The next section covers it.
- Renegotiate or split the gap. If the value holds, many sellers will meet at or near the appraised price, especially when the comparable evidence is clear. A middle price is common when both sides want the sale to close.
- Decide: cover the gap or walk. You can bring the difference in cash if you have it and still believe the house is worth the price to you, though think about what the market will support if you resell. Or, if your contract has an appraisal or financing contingency and the dates are still open, you may be able to cancel and keep your deposit. Read the contract and call your agent or attorney before you rely on it.
Steps 3 and 4 can run at the same time. Just do not let the contingency deadline pass while you wait.
How does the ROV step work?
I wrote the step-by-step in What Is a Reconsideration of Value? The short version:
- Start with the report. Federal rules require the lender to give you a copy of the appraisal promptly, or at least three days before closing, whichever is earlier.
- Request it through the lender. You cannot normally contact the appraiser directly. The lender is the client.
- Send evidence, not opinions. A handful of closed sales in the same micro-neighborhood and of similar size, style and condition, with dates before the appraisal's effective date. Fannie Mae's guidance lets a borrower's request include up to five comparables.
For conventional loans backed by Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac, lenders have been required, for applications dated on or after August 29, 2024, to have a written process for borrower reconsideration requests and to tell borrowers how to start one. Ask your loan officer for theirs. The appraiser still makes the final call.
Contract price, asking prices and online estimates are not evidence. In Baltimore, they are also the first things I see in a weak request.
Do FHA loans work differently?
Yes, and the rules have changed. In 2024 HUD created a borrower-initiated reconsideration process. In March 2025, HUD rescinded it in Mortgagee Letter 2025-08. Today, under FHA rules as I read them, the underwriter can ask the appraiser to reconsider when the appraiser missed information that existed on the appraisal's effective date, and a second appraisal can be ordered only when the underwriter finds the first one materially deficient and the appraiser cannot or will not correct it. The lender documents that and pays for the second appraisal.
So on an FHA loan, your leverage is to give your loan officer clear, factual evidence and ask the underwriter to consider it. Rules change, so confirm with your lender what applies to your loan.
What can a seller do?
A seller cannot file the request. The borrower does, through the lender. But a seller can help in three ways:
- Hand over the facts the buyer needs: permits, receipts, a floor plan, and a list of upgrades with dates.
- Provide closed comparables through the agents. A listing agent often knows sales that did not make it into the appraiser's search.
- Decide the price you will accept before the appraisal comes back. Having a number ready prevents a stalemate.
Sellers who want fewer surprises can order a pre-listing appraisal before they list, usually $425 to $575 with me. It gives you a supported value before you set the price, and you can use it to show buyers how you arrived at your number. It does not replace the lender's appraisal.
What should you not do?
- Do not pressure the appraiser to hit a number. Appraisers are required to stay independent, and a request that reads as pressure will hurt you.
- Do not order a private appraisal to shop for a higher value without asking the lender. Most lenders will not accept it in place of their own.
- Do not let the contingency date slip. A reconsideration request takes time, and a missed deadline can cost you your leverage or your deposit.
- Do not submit a long argument. Short, factual, with attachments, wins.
Common questions
Can I challenge a low home appraisal?
Yes. Ask your lender for the report and its reconsideration process, then submit specific errors and closed comparable sales. The appraiser decides whether to change the value.
What happens if the home appraises below the contract price?
The lender bases the loan on the lower value. The buyer and seller can renegotiate the price, split the gap, or the buyer can cover the difference in cash. A buyer may cancel if the contract has an appraisal or financing contingency.
Can a seller dispute the appraisal?
Not directly. The borrower submits the request through the lender, but a seller can supply facts and comparable sales through the agents.
Can I get a second appraisal?
Sometimes. FHA allows a second appraisal only when the underwriter finds the first materially deficient. For conventional loans, the lender decides. Ask before paying for anything.
Do I get a copy of my appraisal?
Yes. Federal rules require lenders to provide a copy of the appraisal promptly or three days before closing, whichever is earlier.
Sources
- HUD Mortgagee Letter 2025-08 (rescinds ML 2024-07 reconsideration process)
- Consumer Finance Monitor: Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac reconsideration of value guidance
- Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: appraisal copies rule
This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Rules and lender procedures change and every transaction is different. Confirm current requirements with your lender, a Maryland attorney, your CPA or a title company.