Appraisals & Lending

Appraising a Baltimore Duplex or Small Multifamily Property: How Two-to-Four Unit Values Are Determined

A duplex is not just a bigger house. It is a home and an income stream, and the appraisal has to account for both. Here is how I value two-to-four unit properties in Baltimore, and what buyers, owners and lenders should know.

A row of Baltimore brick duplexes and small apartment buildings with an income and rent chart, with the title Appraising a Baltimore Duplex or Small Multifamily Property by Ed Drost.
A two-to-four unit building is valued as a home and as an income property.

Home › Articles › Appraising a Duplex or Small Multifamily

Direct answer

A Baltimore duplex, triplex or fourplex is typically appraised on Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac Form 1025, the Small Residential Income Property Appraisal Report. The appraiser compares sales of similar two-to-four unit properties, analyzes actual and market rents, and considers an income approach such as the gross rent multiplier. The property's legal use, rental licensing and condition also affect value. Properties with five or more units are generally valued as commercial or multifamily.

A duplex in Highlandtown, a triplex in Hampden or a four-unit building in Waverly: each one is a place to live and a source of income. Appraising it means getting both right.

Multifamily is one of the specialties I have worked in most since I started appraising in September 1989. Baltimore has one of the largest stocks of small rental buildings in the Mid-Atlantic, from classic two-family rowhouses and converted single-family homes to purpose-built fourplexes. Here is how the valuation works, and where owners and buyers most often get tripped up.

What counts as a small multifamily property?

For residential lending purposes, a "small multifamily" or "small residential income property" has two to four units: a duplex, triplex or fourplex. These are financed with residential mortgages, including FHA, VA and conventional loans, and appraised with residential forms.

A property with five or more units is generally treated as commercial or multifamily, with different lenders, different underwriting and a different valuation approach that leans much more heavily on income. If you are looking at a five-unit building, it is a different assignment.

What report does the appraiser use for a duplex, triplex or fourplex?

For two-to-four unit properties, the standard report is Form 1025, the Small Residential Income Property Appraisal Report (Freddie Mac Form 72). It is used when an interior and exterior inspection is required, and it goes much further than the one-unit form. It includes:

That extra analysis is the reason a 2–4 unit appraisal takes longer and costs more than a single-family appraisal. In my published fee guide, two-to-four unit buildings run about $650 to $900, depending on the number of units and complexity.

How is a duplex's value actually determined?

I use up to three lines of reasoning and reconcile them.

1. Sales comparison

I find recent sales of similar two-to-four unit properties in the same market area and adjust for differences: location, size, number of units, condition, unit mix, parking, basements and updates. In a market like Baltimore, finding true comparables can be the hard part. A two-family brick rowhouse in Canton and a similar-looking building ten blocks inland may be valued very differently.

2. Income approach

Rents matter because buyers of rental property pay for income. The most common residential tool is the gross rent multiplier (GRM): the sale price divided by the gross monthly rent. If comparable properties sold for about 95 times their monthly rent, and your building's market rent is $3,000 a month, the indicated value is roughly $285,000. (Illustrative numbers only.) GRMs vary by neighborhood, building condition and rent level, so I derive them from actual sales in the area.

Appraisers may look at both actual rents (what tenants are paying under leases) and market rents (what the units would likely rent for today). The two can differ a lot if leases are old, rents are below market, or an owner lives in one unit.

3. Cost approach

For newer or unusual buildings, the cost approach, which estimates replacement cost less depreciation plus land value, can be a useful cross-check. For older Baltimore buildings it usually carries the least weight.

What features affect a duplex's value most?

How do Baltimore's rental rules affect an appraisal?

Local rules can affect marketability, so I pay attention to them.

Rental licensing. Baltimore City requires rental properties to be registered, inspected and licensed to operate as rentals. Since January 1, 2019 this includes non-owner-occupied one- and two-family dwellings, not only larger buildings. A landlord without a current license may lose the right to collect rent in court. Ask whether the license is current.

Lead paint. Maryland requires owners of rental properties built before 1978 to register them with the Maryland Department of the Environment and meet lead risk reduction standards, including at each change of occupancy. A multifamily building with unresolved lead issues carries compliance cost and risk.

Ground rent. Many Baltimore rowhouses and small multifamily buildings are on ground rent. It affects the owner's equity and should be identified and, where applicable, redeemed. See Ground Rent and Home Value.

These are not appraisal items themselves, but they affect what a buyer will pay, what a lender will finance and how I describe the property.

How does FHA treat two-to-four unit properties?

FHA allows owner-occupant buyers to finance a two-to-four unit property with a low down payment, provided the buyer lives in one of the units. A few points matter for the appraisal:

Because the self-sufficiency result depends on the appraiser's rent figures, ask your lender to run a rough version of the test before you make an offer on a triplex or fourplex. Your lender's exact requirements apply.

How should owners and buyers prepare?

Common questions

Is a duplex appraised differently from a single-family home?

Yes. The appraiser uses a different report form, analyzes rents, and considers an income approach in addition to comparing sales. Condition and legal use of each unit also receive closer attention.

What is a gross rent multiplier?

It is the sale price divided by the gross rent, usually monthly, from comparable properties. Applied to your property's market rent, it gives an indicated value. It is a quick way to relate income to price, and it is only as reliable as the comparable data behind it.

Do tenants have to let the appraiser in?

Access is governed by the lease and by notice requirements. Owners usually arrange access with proper notice. If the appraiser cannot see a unit, the report may carry limitations or be delayed.

How much does a duplex appraisal cost in Baltimore?

My typical range for two-to-four unit properties is about $650 to $900, depending on size, number of units and complexity. See the Baltimore Home Appraisal Cost Guide.

Can you appraise a portfolio of small rental properties?

Yes. I do portfolio and bulk assignments for investors and lenders with consistent methodology. See Portfolio and Bulk Appraisals in Baltimore.

The bottom line

A small multifamily property is two valuations in one: a place people live and a business that pays. Good data on sales, rents, condition and legal use produces a number you can rely on, whether you are buying, refinancing, settling an estate or planning a sale. The details are specific to each building, and in Baltimore, so are the surprises.

Buying, refinancing or selling a Baltimore duplex or small multifamily building? Call me for a clear, well-supported opinion of value.

Sources

This article is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. All dollar examples are hypothetical and rules change, so confirm current requirements with your lender, a Maryland attorney, your CPA or a title company.

Share:FacebookLinkedInEmail
Need a certified Baltimore appraisal? Free quotes. Certified, local and defensible.
Call 443-904-5229